Pros and Cons of Roof Repair vs Roof Replacement

how roofing installation is good

Roof repair and replacement each have their time and place, but it can be challenging for homeowners to know which one is the right choice for them. That is why we created this comprehensive list of pro and con factors, including time, cost, aesthetics, environmental impact, and lifespan, to help you determine which option is suitable for your roof.

Pros and Cons of Roof Repair vs Roof Replacement

Time of Roof Repair vs Roof Replacement

One of the most significant concerns homeowners have when it comes to roof repair and replacement is the time it will take and how the construction will impact their lives. A pro of roof repair is that it is usually completed in one day, typically within a couple of hours. By running your daily errands, they would be done before your get back.

A con of a full roof replacement is that it takes time. While some small homes may take a single day, you can likely expect two to three days for a full replacement. Bear in mind that some factors, such as inclement weather, extensive repairs, or a complicated house design, may increase the timeline. If you work from home and need a quiet space, you will need to make other arrangements for the duration of the construction as it is quite loud.

Cost of Repairing vs Replacing Roof

When it comes to roof repair versus replacement, a roof repair is most certainly going to be the cheaper option. Depending on how extensive your repairs are, you could get away with spending as little as $150. However, according to Forbes, the current national average for roof repairs in America sits under $1000 at $950.

While a lower cost is a pro of roof repairs, repair costs will vary wildly depending on what you need. You will likely be looking at a few thousand dollars if you have severe damage and need significant repairs to address issues like water damage, mold, chimney repair, and other large problems.

For a total roof replacement, homeowners average a cost of $8000 for a moderately sized home. Obviously, the bigger the house and the larger the roof, the more expensive it will be.

Roofing Aesthetics

roof installation benefits and negatives

Your roof is a major component of your home’s exterior aesthetics. A con of roof repair is that you will likely have a mismatched roof. This is due to the fact that getting an exact shingle match can be difficult. Even if the roofer can find the precise shingle you used initially, they still are unlikely to match because your original shingles will have faded some due to exposure to the elements. Therefore, a con of roof repair is the changes may stick out and create a patchwork look to your home.

A full roof replacement is often preferred when it comes to aesthetics. Since it is all new material, it will all match. Plus, you will be able to change the color or style of the shingle to suit a new aesthetic if you so choose.

Environmental Impact

When it comes to the environmental impact of roof repair versus roof replacement, each option has its pros.

The pro of a roof repair is that you save unnecessary waste from ending up in the landfill. Research from 2011 found that 11 million tons of asphalt shingle waste are generated yearly. Therefore, if you don’t need a full replacement yet, you can help the planet by choosing a simple repair instead.

If you do need a full roof replacement, there are environmental benefits as well. While you will be generating waste, you will be updating your home with a higher-quality roof. New technology and manufacturing have demonstrated that the materials we use today provide greater energy efficiency for homeowners. Therefore, going with an updated roof will waste less energy (and money).

Lifespan of your Roof

The lifespan of your roof is a critical component to consider when debating between a roof repair and a roof replacement. For example, if you have a healthy roof with minor damage, a simple roof repair could add years to your roof’s lifespan at a fraction of the cost. A serious pro!

On the other hand, if your roof is nearing the end of its lifespan, a full replacement may be a better choice. There is no point in repairing a roof that will need to replace soon anyway; you may as well get it over with and skip doubling up on costs. Plus, you can rest assured that your roof is good to go for another 15 to 30 years.

Both options have significant pros but rely heavily on your roof’s current age and condition. To better understand which option would be better, you would need a roof inspection.

When Should I Get Roof Repair vs. Roof Replacement

Keeping the above considerations in mind, we recommend the following to determine whether you should get roof repair versus roof replacement.

For minor roof damage, such as a few missing shingles or isolated wind damage, roof repair is all you need. A quick patch job will keep you in good shape.

For moderate roof damage, the answer can waffle between a simple repair or a total replacement. If the roof damage is confined to one area of the roof, we recommend utilizing replacement. However, if it is sprinkled throughout the entire roof, it may be better to get a complete replacement.

For severe damage, you will most likely need a full roof replacement as soon as possible. Remember, your roof is what protects your home, and it if the damage is left unattended, it could cause a myriad of other structural problems.

Call to Get a Free Roof Replacement Quote

roof installation pros and cons

Do you have an asphalt roof in need of some TLC? Roof Maxx is the Tri-Cities’ top choice for roof repair, replacement, and treatment. When it comes to convenience, cost, and time we make every effort to ensure that you get the perfect solution for your roof problem.

For more information on our services, please visit our website. Would you like a quote on your roofing needs? Give us a call today to get a free quote!